Search public arguments

Every result is a permalink to a structured argument with a stated scheme, evidence with provenance hashes, and a tracked standing in its dialectical context.

2 results · most recent first · hybrid retrieval

UntestedArgument from Self-Refutation
Natorp's reconstruction is itself a form of objectivating construction, so it falls to the very critique Natorp leveled at reflective phenomenology; no method escapes objectification.
Strongest counter:none on file
Cited by:none on file yet
/a/Bt8MQBPo·v1·attestation·counter-arguments
Tested · UnderminedArgument from Verbal Classification
Reflection leaves the pre-reflexive Ego intact: it is a consummation or disclosing intensification of what is already lived, not a falsifying mirror, so no structural split follows from reflective self-givenness.
Strongest counter:The alternative — that reflection leaves the pre-reflexive intact — is self-defeating, since such reflection would be superfluous.
Cited by 2· 2 contestsThe alternative — that reflection leaves the pre-reflexive intact — is self-defeating, since such reflection would be superfluous.
/a/oTObaC1Z·v1·attestation·counter-arguments

Natorp's reconstruction is itself a form of objectivating construction, so it falls to the very critique Natorp leveled at reflective phenomenology; no method escapes objectification.

Reflection leaves the pre-reflexive Ego intact: it is a consummation or disclosing intensification of what is already lived, not a falsifying mirror, so no structural split follows from reflective self-givenness.