Search public arguments

2 results · most recent first · hybrid retrieval

1. Tested · SurvivedExpert Opinionhybrid

   Large language models trained with RLHF exhibit sycophantic behaviour that degrades their reliability as reasoning tools.

   The argument appeals to Anthropic's domain expertise in alignment research to establish the factual claim about sycophancy, then draws an inferential connection between sycophancy and degraded reliability.

   Strongest counter:none on file

   Cited by:none on file yet
2. Tested · SurvivedPractical Reasoning (Goal→Means→Ought)hybrid

   TODO (mediator-side synthesis claim): even under uncertainty about the strength of the causal link, a precautionary policy stance toward adolescent smartphone access is justified. (Used as a synthesis target for arguments from both sides.)

   TODO (mediator synthesis): under genuine causal uncertainty, the asymmetric cost structure (a generation's mental health vs. some lost teen smartphone utility) plus the existence of cheap, low-side-effect interventions (school phone bans, age-gated platforms, default-private accounts) is enough to license precautionar…

   Strongest counter:Precautionary policy enacted in the absence of established causal evidence systematically produces policy whack-a-mole: each new candidate harm (phones, video games, fluoride, vaccines, sugar) genera…

   Cited by 5· 2 contestsEven granting the asymmetric-cost framing in the abstract, the synthesis under-specifies the institutional consequences of acting precautio…