aif version: AIF-Core-2011
mesh aif profile: 1.0
exported at: 2026-08-30T19:18:36.155Z
attestation:
  identifier: nmTTNUsZ
  argument id: cmj216jnw0009g1xvhcwrv2kt
  permalink: https://www.isonomia.app/a/nmTTNUsZ
  version: 1
  immutable permalink: https://www.isonomia.app/a/nmTTNUsZ@c0f81e6a3a94e17639d47de9b85c38a257005f0f2612ec741a40368bb8c8e205
  iso id: iso:argument:nmTTNUsZ
  iso url: https://www.isonomia.app/iso/argument/nmTTNUsZ
  retrieved at: 2026-08-30T19:18:35.981Z
  created at: 2025-12-11T22:49:51.884Z
  updated at: 2025-12-11T22:49:51.884Z
  conclusion:
    claim id: cmj213iwp000pg1rs1pw2c6nj
    text: Carbon taxes risk harming economic competitiveness and low-income households.
  premises:
    claim id: cmj213jhe000rg1rsn823gnxd
    text: Energy costs would increase 15-25% under a $50/ton carbon tax.
    is implicit: false
  premises:
    claim id: cmj213k2c000tg1rsdlli4aoo
    text: Energy-intensive industries may relocate to jurisdictions without carbon pricing.
    is implicit: false
  premises:
    claim id: cmj213kn3000vg1rsuh5ufjd9
    text: Low-income households spend a larger share of income on energy.
    is implicit: false
  scheme:
    id: cmghcusvd000lzq6mf0qmkrnf
    key: negative_consequences
    name: Argument from Negative Consequences
    canonical key: negative_consequences
    catalogue health:
      is argument pattern: true
      is dialogue meta: false
      is test placeholder: false
      canonical key: negative_consequences
      cluster tag missing: false
      fingerprint materialised: true
  critical questions:
    scheme key: negative_consequences
    total: 3
    unanswered:
      cq key: NC.LIKELIHOOD
      text: Are the stated bad consequences likely to occur?
      attack kind: UNDERCUTS
      scheme key: negative_consequences
      premise type: ORDINARY
      is scheme required: true
      inherited from parent scheme: false
      challenged: false
      challenge count: 0
      cq requires evidence: false
      cq burden: PROPONENT
      answer self canonical: false
      answer author kind: HUMAN
      status: missing
    unanswered:
      cq key: NC.MITIGATION
      text: Can the bad effects be mitigated so they are acceptable?
      attack kind: REBUTS
      scheme key: negative_consequences
      premise type: ORDINARY
      is scheme required: true
      inherited from parent scheme: false
      challenged: false
      challenge count: 0
      cq requires evidence: false
      cq burden: PROPONENT
      answer self canonical: false
      answer author kind: HUMAN
      status: missing
    unanswered:
      cq key: NC.TRADEOFFS
      text: Are there benefits that outweigh the bad effects?
      attack kind: REBUTS
      scheme key: negative_consequences
      premise type: ORDINARY
      is scheme required: true
      inherited from parent scheme: false
      challenged: false
      challenge count: 0
      cq requires evidence: false
      cq burden: PROPONENT
      answer self canonical: false
      answer author kind: HUMAN
      status: missing
  dialectical status:
    incoming attacks: 0
    incoming supports: 0
    incoming attack edges: 0
    critical questions required: 3
    critical questions answered: 0
    critical questions open: 3
    standing score: 0.5
    is tested: false
    testedness: untested
    standing state: untested-default
    standing depth:
      challengers: 0
      independent reviewers: 0
      confidence: thin
    fitness breakdown:
      total: 0
      weights:
        cq answered: 1
        support edges: 0.5
        attack edges: -0.7
        attack c as: -1
        evidence with provenance: 0.25
  deliberation: Ludics Forest Demo - Phase 1-4 Features
    id: ludics-forest-demo
  author:
    id: 12
    display name: Barthes
    kind: HUMAN
round trip soundness:
  scheme key: negative_consequences
  groups:
    ORDINARY:
      cq count: 3
      aif exposure: exposed
    ASSUMPTION:
      cq count: 0
      aif exposure: absent
    EXCEPTION:
      cq count: 0
      aif exposure: absent
  lossy: false

cmj213iwp000pg1rs1pw2c6nj
type: InformationNode
text: Carbon taxes risk harming economic competitiveness and low-income households.

cmj213jhe000rg1rsn823gnxd
type: InformationNode
text: Energy costs would increase 15-25% under a $50/ton carbon tax.

cmj213k2c000tg1rsdlli4aoo
type: InformationNode
text: Energy-intensive industries may relocate to jurisdictions without carbon pricing.

cmj213kn3000vg1rsuh5ufjd9
type: InformationNode
text: Low-income households spend a larger share of income on energy.

cmj216jnw0009g1xvhcwrv2kt
type: RA
type: negative consequences
uses scheme: negative_consequences
name: Argument from Negative Consequences
applies scheme key: negative_consequences

Premise
from: I:cmj213jhe000rg1rsn823gnxd
to: S:cmj216jnw0009g1xvhcwrv2kt

Premise
from: I:cmj213k2c000tg1rsdlli4aoo
to: S:cmj216jnw0009g1xvhcwrv2kt

Premise
from: I:cmj213kn3000vg1rsuh5ufjd9
to: S:cmj216jnw0009g1xvhcwrv2kt

Conclusion
from: S:cmj216jnw0009g1xvhcwrv2kt
to: I:cmj213iwp000pg1rs1pw2c6nj

count: 0
weight: 1
contribution: 0

count: 0
weight: 0.5
contribution: 0

count: 0
weight: -0.7
contribution: 0

count: 0
weight: -1
contribution: 0

count: 0
weight: 0.25
contribution: 0