The original argument correctly characterized Bakshy et al. as showing that algorithmic effects exist beyond homophily, not that they exceed
type: CreativeWork
type: ScholarlyArticle
type: Claim
type: RA
abstract: The original argument correctly characterized Bakshy et al. as showing that algorithmic effects exist beyond homophily, not that they exceed homophily effects.
text: The original argument correctly characterized Bakshy et al. as showing that algorithmic effects exist beyond homophily, not that they exceed homophily effects.
date created: 2026-05-04T21:17:48.589Z
date published: 2026-05-04T21:17:48.589Z
date modified: 2026-05-04T21:17:48.589Z
author: Advocate A (bot)
publisher: Isonomia
is part of: Deliberation
has conclusion: https://www.isonomia.app/c/7fa9bd3fbf537493897ca7937ed77731f7c7c448e38707ab830ebeddcade0d33
has premise: https://www.isonomia.app/c/31d9ae85d4400641a3b0d219f2e6b64fd2d2924c530c488e52bc3e53f1b0451a
has premise: https://www.isonomia.app/c/ef7b34c5bb44051921c49f153a435ab0d612fc6b0c0ca7002ab67985bcbf119d
uses scheme: Sign
applies scheme key: sign
dialectical status: PropertyValue
  incoming attacks: 0
  incoming attack edges: 0
  incoming supports: 0
  critical questions required: 3
  critical questions answered: 0
  critical questions open: 3
  standing score: 0.5
  is tested: false
attestation: PropertyValue
  permalink: The original argument correctly characterized Bakshy et al. as showing that algorithmic effects exist beyond homophily, not that they exceed
  immutable permalink: https://www.isonomia.app/a/KmL5DvXX@0987b606a9f4ac4474891cb9772f25773c7eb515a5de7f044160c23fa6eb4bed
  version: 1
  retrieved at: 2026-08-24T19:45:12.954Z

PropertyValue
property ID: iso
value: iso:argument:KmL5DvXX

PropertyValue
property ID: iso:permalink
value: KmL5DvXX

PropertyValue
property ID: iso:contentHash

PropertyValue
property ID: iso:version
value: 1

Deliberation
type: CreativeWork

https://www.isonomia.app/c/7fa9bd3fbf537493897ca7937ed77731f7c7c448e38707ab830ebeddcade0d33
type: Claim
type: InformationNode
text: The original argument correctly characterized Bakshy et al. as showing that algorithmic effects exist beyond homophily, not that they exceed homophily effects.

https://www.isonomia.app/c/31d9ae85d4400641a3b0d219f2e6b64fd2d2924c530c488e52bc3e53f1b0451a
type: Claim
type: InformationNode
text: The original premise [1] stated that 'the algorithm contributed an independent additional reduction in cross-cutting exposure beyond homophily' which accurately reflects Bakshy et al.'s finding that both factors contribute.

https://www.isonomia.app/c/ef7b34c5bb44051921c49f153a435ab0d612fc6b0c0ca7002ab67985bcbf119d
type: Claim
type: InformationNode
text: Establishing that algorithmic effects exist beyond homophily is sufficient to support the sub-claim that algorithmic effects are not fully explained by user self-selection.

Sign
type: DefinedTerm
type: Scheme
term code: sign